The short answer
A failed check valve or relief valve on an assembly that is otherwise sound is usually a rebuild, using a kit of seats, discs and springs for that specific model. Replacement is the answer when the body is cracked or corroded through, when the model is old enough that rebuild kits are no longer made, when it has failed repeatedly, or when it is the wrong type or size for the hazard it is protecting. Either way, the assembly has to be retested after the work and the passing report submitted.
This page is about what to do after a failure. If you are looking for the annual test itself, that is a different job and it is covered on our backflow testing page.
What the test is actually measuring
A backflow assembly stops water that has left the potable supply from coming back into it. On an irrigation system that matters, because the water in those lines has been sitting in pipes, around fertilizer, and in contact with the ground. The assembly is the thing standing between that and the drinking water.
A tester connects gauges to the test cocks on the assembly and checks each internal component separately: whether each check valve holds against reverse pressure, and on a reduced pressure type, whether the relief valve opens at the right differential. That is why a report says which part failed rather than just saying the assembly failed, and that detail is what decides repair or replacement.
Reading your failure report
| What the report says failed | What it usually means | Likely path |
|---|---|---|
| First or second check valve did not hold | Debris on the seat, or a worn rubber disc and spring | Rebuild kit. Often the cheapest outcome |
| Relief valve opened late, early, or not at all | Worn relief valve components or a fouled sensing passage | Rebuild kit for the relief valve |
| Relief valve discharging continuously | Usually debris holding a check open, sometimes fluctuating supply pressure | Often a clean and rebuild rather than a replacement |
| Body cracked, corroded, or leaking from the casting | The housing itself has failed | Replacement. A body cannot be rebuilt |
| No parts available for the model | The assembly is out of production and unsupported | Replacement, regardless of which component failed |
What usually causes a failure here
- Debris on a seat. A single grain of grit is enough to hold a check valve open, which is why some failures clean up without new parts.
- Hard water scale on the internal seats and springs, building up over seasons until the components stop seating cleanly.
- Rubber that has hardened with age and sun, especially on an assembly mounted above ground in full exposure.
- Freeze damage. Mild winters here still produce the occasional night that cracks a body or splits a bonnet on an unprotected assembly.
- Thermal expansion and pressure fluctuation in the supply working on the relief valve over time.
Why a cheap outcome is a real possibility
A meaningful share of first-time failures come down to debris rather than worn parts. Cleaning and reseating can return the assembly to passing without a rebuild kit at all. That is worth knowing before anyone quotes a replacement off the back of a failure notice.
Repair economics, honestly
Rebuild kits cost a fraction of a new assembly, and the labor is comparable, so a rebuild is usually the better value when the body is sound and parts are available. That changes in three situations. An assembly that has failed in consecutive years is telling you something. An assembly near the end of a product line will get harder to source parts for every year. And an assembly that was undersized or is the wrong type for the hazard was never going to be right, and rebuilding it just preserves the original mistake.
There is also the reduced pressure versus double check question. These are different device types for different hazard levels, and you do not get to choose the cheaper one. What the system is protecting against determines which type is required, so an assembly being replaced has to be matched to that rather than to the budget.
The part people miss: the retest
Repairing or replacing the assembly is not the end of it. It has to be tested again after the work and the passing report submitted to whoever required the test, within whatever window they set. A repair that never gets retested and filed leaves you exactly as non-compliant as the original failure did, and that is the most common way this goes wrong administratively.
So when you arrange the repair, confirm who is doing the retest, who is submitting the report, and what the deadline is. Those three questions prevent nearly every follow-up problem.
Talk to a licensed Las Vegas plumber
We will tell you which component failed and whether it is a rebuild before quoting a replacement, because on a sound body a rebuild is usually the right answer. Kingdom Plumbing is family-owned, licensed, bonded and insured (NV Contractors License #0085422), with commercial and property management experience as well as residential. Call (702) 840-5037 or see commercial plumbing.
Frequently Asked Questions
My backflow assembly failed its test. Do I need a new one?
Why did my backflow assembly fail?
How much does it cost to fix a failed backflow assembly?
Does the assembly have to be retested after a repair?
What is the difference between a double check and a reduced pressure assembly?
Can I keep using my irrigation while the assembly is failed?
Have a plumbing question or a problem right now?
Call (702) 840-5037Burst pipe or flooding that can't wait? Our 24/7 emergency plumbers in Las Vegas dispatch around the clock.



